Independent Representatives of Tnemec Company, Inc.Colorado · Wyoming · MontanaHow long will a water tank coating last?
Predicted service life and life-cycle cost for every AWWA D102 inside (ICS) and outside (OCS) coating system, based on about 180 North American water tank case histories and comparative performance testing.
Inside coating systems (ICS)
Life-cycle cost is the installed cost divided by the years of service: the lowest cost per square foot per year is the best value. Percentages are relative to the lowest-cost inside system.
| AWWA D102 | Coating system | Thickness (mils) | Industry opinion, 2018 (years) | Predicted service life (years) | Life-cycle cost vs. lowest | Value | EPR systems |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| ICS No. 1 | Two-coat solventated epoxy | 8.0 | 12 | 18.5 | +7% | Better | PW-S1.9 |
| ICS No. 2 | Three-coat solventated epoxy | 12.0 | 15 | 22 | +13% | Better | PW-S1.10, PW-S1.14, PW-S1.16 |
| ICS No. 3 | High-solids epoxy | 20.0 | 18 | 26 | +11% | Better | PW-S1.15 |
| ICS No. 3 with zinc | High-solids epoxy over a zinc-rich primer | 22.5 | - | 30 | +6% | Best | PW-S1.1, PW-S1.12 |
| ICS No. 4 | 100% solids aromatic polyurethane | 25.0 | 18 | 16 | +111% | Lowest value | - |
| ICS No. 4 with zinc | 100% solids aromatic polyurethane over a zinc-rich primer | 27.5 | - | 20 | +84% | Lowest value | - |
| ICS No. 5 | Two-coat solventated epoxy over a zinc-rich primer | 10.0 | 16 | 22.5 | +8% | Better | PW-S1.2 |
| ICS No. 6 | One-coat solventated epoxy over a zinc-rich primer | 12.5 | - | 24 | Lowest | Best | PW-S1.8 |
Outside coating systems (OCS)
Percentages are relative to the lowest-cost outside system.
| AWWA D102 | Coating system | Thickness (mils) | Industry opinion, 2018 (years) | Predicted service life (years) | Life-cycle cost vs. lowest | Value | EPR systems |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| OCS No. 1 | Alkyd | 4.0 or 6.0 | 17 | Not enough information | - | - | - |
| OCS No. 2 | Moisture-cure urethane | 7.0 | 29 | Not enough information | - | - | - |
| OCS No. 3 | Acrylic over a zinc-rich primer | 6.5 | 21 | 16 | +81% | Lowest value | - |
| OCS No. 4 | Fluoropolymer over a zinc-rich primer and polyurethane intermediate | 6.5 | 34 | 30 | Lowest | Best | PW-S3.1 |
| OCS No. 5 | Polyurethane over an epoxy primer and intermediate | 6.5 | 23 | 19 | +53% | Good | PW-S3.2 |
| OCS No. 6 | Polyurethane over a zinc-rich primer and epoxy intermediate | 6.5 | 26 | 23 | +26% | Better | PW-S1.3 |
| OCS No. 7 | Water-based polyurethane over water-based epoxy | 6.0 | 21 | 19 | +52% | Good | - |
What the data shows
- Zinc-rich primers lower the cost per year: one coat of epoxy over zinc (ICS No. 6) is the lowest life-cycle cost inside system, and high-solids epoxy over zinc (ICS No. 3) lasts longest, at a predicted 30 years.
- Thicker epoxy lasts longer: three coats of epoxy (ICS No. 2, 12 mils) outlasted two coats (ICS No. 1, 8 mils) by a median of 3.5 years in the case histories.
- 100% solids aromatic polyurethane linings (ICS No. 4) had a median service life of 15 years in the case histories, below the 18 years claimed in 2018, and the highest life-cycle cost of any inside system.
- Fluoropolymer over zinc (OCS No. 4) has the lowest life-cycle cost of the outside systems, with a predicted 30-year service life.
- Polyurethane over a zinc-rich primer (OCS No. 6) is predicted to last 4 years longer than polyurethane over an epoxy primer (OCS No. 5).
- There is not enough case history or test data to predict the service life of alkyd (OCS No. 1) or moisture-cure urethane (OCS No. 2) systems.
Equal is not always equal
Products with the same generic name can perform very differently. In a Southern Nevada water utility (SNWA) study of seven linings all marketed as meeting the same AWWA requirements, results varied by more than 100% on 15 of 17 performance tests.
The coating is roughly 3 to 10% of a water tank project's cost, but it decides how soon the tank must be taken out of service and recoated. In the paper, a coating that lasts 25% less raised 80-year coating costs by 23% to 46%.
That is why EPR's specifications ask for case histories, comparative test data and a life-cycle cost analysis before a substitution is accepted.
Life-cycle cost calculator
Enter your installed cost per square foot for each system. Service life starts at the predicted life for its AWWA D102 system; change it to match your own experience.
Planning aid only. Results depend entirely on the costs and service lives you enter. Predicted service lives are estimates from the paper cited below, not a warranty.
| Coating system | Installed cost ($/sq ft) | Service life (years) | Cost per sq ft per year | vs. lowest | Coating cost over the years compared | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Predicted 24 years · Best | - | - | - | |||
Predicted 30 years · Best | - | - | - | |||
Predicted 16 years · Lowest value | - | - | - |
Enter the full installed cost per square foot for each system: surface preparation, materials, labor, containment and access. Cost over the years compared spreads each system's cost over its service life (cost per sq ft per year x years x area); it does not add inflation or interest. Service life starts at the paper's predicted life for each AWWA D102 system and can be changed to match your own case histories.
Source: David Walker and Cameron Walker, Separating Fact From Fiction: AWWA D102 Coating Service Life, Tnemec Company, January 2022. Predicted service life is the paper's final 2021 estimate, from case histories (end of life: more than 5% of the coating failing per SSPC-VIS 2) and comparative performance testing. Life-cycle cost percentages are the paper's, from 2020 tendered projects; EPR does not republish its dollar figures.
These are estimates for welded steel potable water tanks, not a warranty. Actual service life depends on the tank, environment, surface preparation, application, inspection and maintenance. EPR systems are matched to the AWWA D102 system with the same coating technology, coats and film build. Questions? Call (303) 431-7334 or contact us.
